About us

Founded in 1985 in Bay Shore, Coyle’s Ice Cream has been dedicated to serving the community high-quality, homemade treats for nearly four decades. From our small beginnings, we've grown into a beloved staple known for our commitment to freshness, flavor, and friendly service. Each of our ice cream creations is crafted with care, featuring locally sourced ingredients and traditional recipes that keep our guests coming back for more. At Coyle’s, we believe in creating a welcoming space where families and friends can gather, share memories, and indulge in the timeless joy of an ice cream cone, a sundae, or a nostalgic classic.

Taste The Tradition!

Step into Coyle's and enjoy a timeless scoop, a towering sundae, or one of our nostalgic classics. Our doors are always open for those who seek a warm welcome, an ice cream adventure, and a little piece of Bay Shore’s sweetest tradition. Come indulge in our beloved treats today!

Call us at 631 666 2229

[data-wf-bgvideo-fallback-img] { display: none; } @media (prefers-reduced-motion: reduce) { [data-wf-bgvideo-fallback-img] { position: absolute; z-index: -100; display: inline-block; height: 100%; width: 100%; object-fit: cover; } }

Locally Sourced

We take pride in supporting local farms and suppliers to ensure the freshest, highest-quality ingredients in every scoop.

100% Homemade

All of our ice cream is made in-house using time-honored recipes, ensuring a fresh and authentic taste with every scoop.

Community-Centered

We take pride in supporting our local community, from partnering with nearby schools and charities to creating a welcoming space for families and friends to come together.

About us

Taste The Tradition!

Locally Sourced

100% Homemade

Community-Centered

Explore